Skip to main content

CRE Returns Hit Four-Year High as Rising Rates Threaten Recovery: 3Q 2026 Webinar Highlights

In the third quarter of 2026, institutional commercial real estate (CRE) delivered its strongest quarterly return since mid-2022, supported by improving net operating income (NOI) growth, resilient property fundamentals and renewed transaction volume. However, rising Treasury yields and mounting refinancing pressures could challenge that momentum heading into year-end. SitusAMC’s Real Estate Valuation Services (REVS) team discussed these trends during the November 19 webinar, “Interpreting the Data: Current Valuation Trends and State of the CRE Market.”  

Participants included Brian Velky, Senior Managing Director, Real Estate Valuation Services; Dane Anderson, Managing Director, Appraisal & Consulting; and Tim Mazzetti, Vice Chairman, Commercial Real Estate. They examined third-quarter performance across the NCREIF Fund Index – Open-End Diversified Core Equity (NFI-ODCE) Index and discussed the implications for fourth-quarter valuations. Drawing on property-level performance, transaction data and SitusAMC’s extensive debt and equity market intelligence, the panel explored the widening chasm between outperforming assets and properties facing mounting financial pressure. Here are the highlights:  

1. ODCE Returns Reach Highest Level Since Mid-2022  

The NFI-ODCE Index posted a 1.71% gross total return in 3Q 2026, its strongest quarterly performance since the market peaked in mid-2022. Returns have now improved for four consecutive quarters, despite a challenging interest-rate environment.  

Approximately 1 percentage point of the quarterly return came from income, while roughly 70 basis points (bps) reflected appreciation, including an estimated 20-bps positive contribution from debt mark-to-market adjustments.  

Although SitusAMC's daily valuation intelligence anticipated a return near 1.7%, the strength of the appreciation component was somewhat unexpected.  

"It certainly surprised me," Velky said, noting that returns between 1.2% and 1.4% would have been more readily explained by underlying fundamentals. The additional appreciation, particularly among funds reporting returns above 2%, was notable given rising borrowing costs.  

The panel cautioned that positive debt mark-to-market adjustments can temporarily support fund-level returns, even as higher rates create subsequent pressure on underlying property valuations.  

2. Rising Treasury Yields Put Fourth-Quarter Valuations Under Pressure  

The 10-year Treasury yield reached approximately 5.1% at the time of the webinar, following an earlier October peak near 5.3%. Expectations for Federal Reserve policy have also shifted dramatically: Anticipated rate cuts at the beginning of 2026 gave way to a 25-bps increase in the third quarter and expectations of additional increases.  

Anderson noted that CRE valuations have weathered substantial rate movements before, including a roughly 150- to 170-bps increase in Treasury yields during the second half of 2023. However, sustained increases are becoming more difficult for investors to absorb, particularly for properties with low going-in cap rates and limited income growth.  

"What's going to drive private real estate values going forward is predominantly that NOI growth story and operational improvements," Anderson said.  

The panel expects fourth-quarter ODCE returns to fall below third-quarter levels, with assets carrying weaker cash flows and significant capital needs particularly vulnerable to higher financing costs.  

3. Office NOI Stabilizes After Years of Declines  

One of the most encouraging developments was the stabilization of office NOI, which was essentially flat in the third quarter after several years of significant deterioration.  

Office NOI declines had previously reached approximately 10% on a trailing annual basis, weighing heavily on overall ODCE performance. The sector also experienced 18 consecutive quarters of negative capital returns, despite seven quarters of positive underlying value changes, reflecting substantial capital expenditure requirements.  

Office occupancy appears to have bottomed in 1Q 2026 and has subsequently improved by more than one percentage point over two quarters. Leasing momentum is strengthening in select markets, with some transactions achieving rents above previously underwritten market leasing assumptions. 

Velky emphasized that the reduction in office's negative contribution to index-wide NOI growth could materially improve overall CRE performance over the next several years.  

Nevertheless, the sector's recovery remains capital-intensive. Tenant improvements and leasing commissions will continue to absorb a meaningful portion of property-level gains, even as occupancy and rents improve.  

4. Retail Maintains Its Lead as Senior Housing NOI Growth Approaches 15%  

Retail continued to demonstrate strong NOI growth and one of the highest income yields among the traditional core property sectors. The panel expects retail to finish 2026 as the best-performing core sector for the fourth consecutive year.  

However, performance remains uneven. Mazzetti pointed to continuing CMBS delinquencies among regional malls, illustrating the chasm between higher-quality retail properties and struggling assets.  

Senior housing was another standout, delivering nearly 15% annual NOI growth within its relatively small ODCE allocation. Favorable demographics, constrained supply and strong investor demand have supported valuations despite rising interest rates.  

Industrial NOI growth has moderated, although stronger leasing in select warehouse and advanced manufacturing markets could support improvement over the next one to two years.  

Residential performance remains mixed. Supply-constrained markets, including San Francisco, Chicago and New York, are showing strength, while parts of the Sun Belt continue to contend with weaker fundamentals. The panel noted that reduced concessions could support residential NOI growth before more substantial increases in market rents materialize.  

5. Transaction Volume Doubles as Pricing Remains Close to Appraised Values  

Third-quarter transaction volume within ODCE doubled from the levels recorded in each of the first two quarters. Approximately 42 transactions totaling $3.3 billion closed during the quarter, with an average transaction size of $78 million and an average cap rate of 5.2%.  

Broader MSCI transaction data indicated that CRE investment volume increased approximately 40% year over year through the first three quarters of 2026. Excluding the significant impact of a major REIT merger, the increase was closer to 20%, according to the panel.  

A comparison of transaction prices with prior appraised values also indicated continued alignment. Across approximately $10 billion of ODCE transactions over the trailing four quarters, properties sold for an average of 1% above their previous-quarter valuations.  

Office transactions averaged 5.8% above prior appraised values, while residential properties showed a negative pricing variance.  

Using valuations from two quarters before the transactions, overall pricing averaged approximately 1% below appraised values. The relatively small differences suggest that institutional appraisals continue to track transaction pricing reasonably closely, although results vary significantly by sector.  

6. Higher Rates Intensify Refinancing and Distress Risks  

Mazzetti offered a perspective from the debt markets, where persistent, elevated rates are increasing pressure on borrowers that previously relied on loan extensions to allow time for stabilization or more favorable refinancing conditions.  

"We expect that there will be increased defaults and delinquencies going forward, especially with an increase in interest rates," Mazzetti said.  

Of particular concern are multifamily properties acquired during 2021 and 2022 at cap rates below 4%, often with aggressive NOI growth projections and short-term financing. Many of those assets now face higher refinancing costs, expanded cap rates and income growth that has fallen short of underwriting assumptions.  

Mazzetti noted that loan modifications previously represented approximately 50% to 60% of loans in CMBS special servicing, with many subsequently returning to performing status. More recently, foreclosures and forced sales have become increasingly prominent as extension options expire.  

These pressures could accelerate distressed asset resolutions, particularly among properties with weaker fundamentals and limited prospects for refinancing.  

7. Asset-Level Fundamentals Drive a Widening Performance Divide  

Throughout the webinar, panelists emphasized the growing divergence between properties generating strong in-place cash flows and those struggling with occupancy, capital spending and refinancing pressures.  

High-quality assets with solid near-term NOI growth and limited capital requirements remain best positioned to preserve or increase value. Conversely, properties dependent on optimistic leasing projections or significant capital investment face greater challenges.  

The differences can be substantial even within individual markets. Newer office buildings with strong amenities may command premium rents while nearby older properties struggle to attract tenants.  

Supply constraints could also support future NOI growth. With higher interest rates and replacement costs limiting new construction, improving demand may generate stronger rent growth in markets where available space is increasingly scarce.  

The panel emphasized that these property-level dynamics are particularly important when evaluating whether projected NOI growth can offset the effect of higher required investment returns.  

Looking Ahead: NOI Growth Faces a Test from Higher Capital Costs  

The REVS team expects fourth-quarter returns to moderate as elevated Treasury yields influence investment decisions, refinancing economics and property valuations.  

While investors continue to transact, persistent rates above 5% have contributed to slower decision-making among buyers and sellers. Residential assets with low initial yields and disappointing NOI growth may face particular pressure, while retail and senior housing appear better positioned.  

The panel expects future appreciation to depend heavily on realized NOI growth, leasing performance and capital expenditure needs, with differences in asset quality continuing to shape returns.  

Watch a recording of the webinar here or download the slides here. For more information on SitusAMC’s Real Estate Valuation Services, visit our website.